Blue Zones: is it a myth?
Reviewed 28 sourcesPublished by PepVault
Is Blue Zones debunked? What the pension-fraud preprint shows, how the demographers answer, why Okinawa and Nicoya slipped, and which habits still hold up.

- Last reviewed
- Sources
- 28
- Questions
- 10
The short answer
Partly. The strongest critique, Saul Newman's study of age records, is still a preprint as of November 2026, and the oldest people of Sardinia, Ikaria and Nicoya passed their researchers' document checks. But Okinawa no longer qualifies, by its own researchers' account, and Nicoya's advantage has faded in men born from the 1930s on. The habits the books list hold up on their own in large studies.
Evidence: Moderate for the original zones: ages were checked against several records but the data are decades old, partly unpublished for Ikaria, and challenged by an unreviewed preprint; high for the habits, from large cohort studies and one diet trial, though none measured lifespan directly.

Where did the Blue Zones idea come from?
It started as demography, not a diet book. In 2004 Michel Poulain and Giovanni Pes counted how many people born in Sardinia between 1880 and 1900 reached 100, village by village, after checking each age against records. Longevity clustered in the mountains of central-eastern Sardinia, and they named that area the Blue Zone1. It was unusual in one more way. Almost everywhere women far outnumber men at 100; in the zone there were 1.35 women per man, against 2.43 in the rest of the island1.
Dan Buettner then led a National Geographic expedition on the idea, and later wrote books, adding Okinawa in Japan, Nicoya in Costa Rica, Ikaria in Greece and the Seventh-day Adventists of Loma Linda, California2. From those five places he drew nine shared habits, the Power 9: move naturally, have a purpose, shed stress, stop eating at 80% full, eat mostly plants and beans, drink one to two glasses of wine a day, and keep close family, friends and a faith community3.

PepVault for iPhone
Keep your protocol in PepVault
PepVault's Food tab shows the day's fiber beside protein and calories, against a daily target set at 14 g per 1,000 calories of your calorie goal, so a bean-heavy, plant-heavy day shows up as a number you can see.
7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.
What does the "Blue Zones debunked" claim actually say?
The claim comes from the researcher Saul Newman. His argument is that extreme ages are mostly paperwork errors and fraud. In the United States, the number of people recorded as reaching 110 fell by 69% to 82% once a state began issuing birth certificates. Only 18% of validated supercentenarians (people over 110) have a birth certificate, and their birthdays cluster on dates divisible by five, which is what made-up dates look like4.
He also found that in Italy, England and France the oldest records come from poorer regions with shorter lives and more crime, and that Sardinia, Okinawa and Ikaria had lower incomes and literacy and shorter life expectancy than their national averages4. A second analysis of 236 countries found that places such as Thailand, Kenya and Malawi rank among the best for reaching 100 despite low life expectancy, which points to bad data rather than long lives6. The work won the 2024 Ig Nobel Prize for demography, for showing that many of the longest lives were in places with "lousy birth-and-death recordkeeping"5.
One fact the headlines skipped: both papers are preprints, meaning posted online without peer review. The pension-fraud paper is on its fourth version (November 2025), and its preprint server lists no published journal version as of November 20264. Newman's earlier, related finding, that small error rates in age records explain why death rates seem to flatten at very old ages, did pass peer review7.
What about Japan's missing centenarians?
In 2010, Japan found the body of a man who would have been 111 and had been dead for decades while his family kept collecting his pension9. The audit that followed found 234,354 people born before 1910 still listed as alive on family registers8. That sounds damning, but demographers who studied the case concluded the effect on Japan's life expectancy figures was "effectively nil"8. Officials then checked registered centenarians in person and found 584 actually missing across the country, out of 44,449, and none of Okinawa's 9228.
Is Okinawa still a Blue Zone?
No, and its defenders say so first: Okinawa "no longer qualifies as a Blue Zone"9. For about 30 years it had Japan's longest life expectancy28; then, in 2002, Okinawan men fell from 4th to 26th of 47 prefectures, a drop the island called a "shock"10. The cause is generational. People born before World War II still die later than other Japanese; those born after die earlier10. The latest prefectural life tables, for 2020, show the split clearly11.
| Okinawa's rank of 47 prefectures, 2020 | Men | Women |
|---|---|---|
| Life expectancy at birth | 43rd (80.73 years; Japan 81.49) | 16th (87.88 years; Japan 87.60) |
| Years left at age 65 | 15th (20.07 years; Japan 19.89) | 1st (25.44 years; Japan 24.77) |
| Years left at age 75 | 2nd (12.93 years; Japan 12.47) | 1st (16.85 years; Japan 16.12) |
The diet changed with them. In 1988 Okinawans ate about 50% more green and yellow vegetables and 30% more beans and pulses than the Japanese average; by 1998 both had fallen to the national level, while meat passed 100 g a day and fat passed 30% of calories12. Poulain himself has called for fresh age checks on some of Okinawa's oldest records10.
Did Nicoya's longevity disappear?
Mostly, for younger men. The original finding was real and specific: from 1990 to 2011, men in Nicoya died at 0.80 times the rate of other elderly Costa Rican men, mainly from less heart disease, and a 60-year-old Nicoyan man was seven times as likely as a Japanese man to reach 100. Women showed no advantage, and men who moved away lost it13.
Then the same demographer, Luis Rosero-Bixby, followed 550,000 Costa Rican adults through 2020. Nicoyan men born in 1905 had 33% lower adult death rates than other Costa Ricans, those born in 1935 only 4% lower, and those born in 1945 10% higher. The low-mortality area has shrunk to a corridor from Hojancha to the beach town of Sámara, home to about 25,000 people against 207,000 in the original zone14.
How do Blue Zones researchers answer the critique?
In a 2025 peer-reviewed reply in The Gerontologist, the aging biologist Steven Austad and Pes make three points9. First, every age in a Blue Zone was cross-checked against several independent records: birth and death registers, church books, military and voting lists, and family trees, plus interviews. In Nicoya, checking 35 claimed centenarians against birth ledgers caught one man who said he was 107 and was not yet 1009. Second, a Blue Zone is defined by the share of people over 90, not by people over 110, so Newman's strongest evidence, on supercentenarians, mostly tests a different claim9. Third, exceptional longevity is not incompatible with poverty, as Okinawa and Sardinia show9. Poulain, who coined the term, sets the bar for a new zone at longevity at least 50% above the national average17.
Independent work supports parts of this: a 2008 check of 8% of Okinawa's centenarians found the ages matched the records15, and a 2025 review of 65 studies by public-health researchers in Spain rated Sardinia's Ogliastra, Okinawa and Nicoya as well characterised16. The weak points are real too: Ikaria's validation rests on an unpublished report written for National Geographic9, and the review found no demographic study of Loma Linda at all16.
Which Blue Zones still hold up?
| Zone | Status as of November 2026 | Main evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Sardinia (central-eastern mountains) | Holds up; validated ages, peer-reviewed | Poulain 20041, Austad and Pes 20259 |
| Ikaria, Greece | Plausible, thinly published | 1.49% of residents over 90 in 2009 vs 0.33% on the Greek mainland, from an unpublished report9 |
| Nicoya, Costa Rica | Real for men born before 1930; fading since | Rosero-Bixby 2013 and 20231314 |
| Okinawa, Japan | No longer a Blue Zone; elders still long-lived | Poulain and Herm 202410, life tables 202011 |
| Loma Linda, California | Not a demographic Blue Zone; a long-lived religious group | Adventist cohort study18; no zone study16 |
The fair verdict: the critique is a serious, unreviewed challenge to extreme age records, not proof that every Blue Zone was fraud. The defence is strongest for Sardinia and weakest for Ikaria. And both sides now agree that a Blue Zone can vanish within a generation914.
Do the Blue Zones habits work anyway?
Yes, and this part does not depend on any village's birth records. The habits have been tested in large cohorts, and the diet in one large trial. A cohort study tracks people's habits and later health; it shows links, not proof of cause (see the observational study entry in our glossary). A hazard ratio of 0.75 means a 25% lower risk of death over the study.
| Habit | What large studies found | Kind of evidence |
|---|---|---|
| Not smoking | Smokers lose more than 10 years of life; quitting before 40 removes about 90% of the excess risk19 | 202,248 US adults |
| All five low-risk habits together | At age 50, 14.0 more years of life for women and 12.2 for men than with none; the five were never smoking, a healthy weight, 30 minutes of exercise a day, a good diet and moderate drinking20 | 123,219 US health workers, up to 34 years |
| Moving more | About 10,900 steps a day vs 3,550: 53% lower risk of death; benefit levels off at 6,000 to 8,000 steps after 6021 | Pooled data, 15 cohorts, 47,471 adults |
| Close social ties | 50% better odds of survival with stronger social relationships22 | 148 studies, 308,849 people |
| Purpose in life | Lowest vs highest purpose: 2.43 times the risk of death over four years23 | 6,985 US adults over 50 |
| Mostly plants | Vegetarians: hazard ratio 0.88 vs non-vegetarians24; a healthy plant-based diet: 0.8425 | 73,308 Adventists; 126,394 UK adults |
| Mediterranean diet with olive oil or nuts | About 30% fewer heart attacks, strokes and heart deaths (hazard ratios 0.69 and 0.72)26 | Randomised trial, 7,447 adults at high heart risk |
The Adventists show what the habits add up to. California Adventists lived 7.3 years longer as men and 4.4 years longer as women than other white Californians, and diet, exercise, weight and smoking explained differences of up to 10 years within the group18. Eating to 80% full, the Okinawan rule, is the subject of our calorie restriction guide.
PepVault's Food tab shows the day's fiber beside protein and calories, against a daily target set at 14 g per 1,000 calories of your calorie goal, so a bean-heavy, plant-heavy day shows up as a number you can see. Track your food in PepVault
Is the daily glass of wine part of it?
This is the Power 9 habit with the weakest support, and the sources disagree. The Blue Zones site says moderate drinkers outlive non-drinkers3, and the five-habit study above counted moderate drinking as a low-risk habit20. A 2023 review of 107 studies and 4.8 million people corrected for a known flaw, which is that many "non-drinkers" in older studies had quit because they were ill. After that, people who drank up to 24 g of alcohol a day (under two US standard drinks) had no significantly lower risk of death than lifelong non-drinkers, and the risk of death rose from about 45 g, three drinks, a day27. The company may count; the alcohol does not appear to add years.
Where to go next
- The longevity hub at pepvault.app/longevity groups the longevity supplements and medicines in our library with their best human evidence.
- Calorie restriction and longevity covers the 80% rule's evidence; VO2 max by age covers fitness and lifespan.
- Cohort studies, meta-analyses and randomised trials are explained at pepvault.app/glossary/observational-study, /glossary/meta-analysis and /glossary/randomized-controlled-trial.
Sources
- Poulain M, Pes GM, Grasland C, et al. Identification of a geographic area characterized by extreme longevity in the Sardinia island: the AKEA study. Exp Gerontol. 2004. PubMed 15489066
- Buettner D, Skemp S. Blue Zones: lessons from the world's longest lived. Am J Lifestyle Med. 2016. PubMed 30202288
- Blue Zones. Power 9: reverse engineering longevity. bluezones.com (read November 20, 2026). bluezones.com
- Newman SJ. Supercentenarian and remarkable age records exhibit patterns indicative of clerical errors and pension fraud. bioRxiv preprint, version 4, November 2025 (not peer reviewed). biorxiv.org
- Improbable Research. The 2024 Ig Nobel Prize winners: Demography, Saul Justin Newman. improbable.com
- Newman SJ. The global pattern of centenarians highlights deep problems in demography. medRxiv preprint, 2024 (not peer reviewed). medrxiv.org
- Newman SJ. Errors as a primary cause of late-life mortality deceleration and plateaus. PLoS Biol. 2018. PubMed 30571676
- Saito Y, Yong V, Robine JM. The mystery of Japan's missing centenarians explained. Demographic Research. 2012;26:239-252. demographic-research.org
- Austad SN, Pes GM. The validity of Blue Zones demography: a response to critiques. Gerontologist. 2025. PubMed 41405258
- Poulain M, Herm A. Exceptional longevity in Okinawa: demographic trends since 1975. J Intern Med. 2024. PubMed 38221516
- Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, Japan. 2020 prefectural life tables (Reiwa 2), summary: life expectancy by prefecture. mhlw.go.jp
- Miyagi S, Iwama N, Kawabata T, Hasegawa K. Longevity and diet in Okinawa, Japan: the past, present and future. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2003. PubMed 18924533
- Rosero-Bixby L, Dow WH, Rehkopf DH. The Nicoya region of Costa Rica: a high longevity island for elderly males. Vienna Yearb Popul Res. 2013. PubMed 25426140
- Rosero-Bixby L. The vanishing advantage of longevity in Nicoya, Costa Rica: a cohort shift. Demographic Research. 2023;49:723-736. demographic-research.org
- Willcox DC, Willcox BJ, He Q, Wang NC, Suzuki M. They really are that old: a validation study of centenarian prevalence in Okinawa. J Gerontol A Biol Sci Med Sci. 2008. PubMed 18426957
- Candal-Pedreira C, Rey-Brandariz J, Martín-Gisbert L, et al. Blue Zones, an analysis of existing evidence through a scoping review. Aging Dis. 2025. PubMed 40479568
- Poulain M, Herm A. Blue Zone, a demographic concept and beyond. Am J Lifestyle Med. 2025. PubMed 40452754
- Fraser GE, Shavlik DJ. Ten years of life: is it a matter of choice? Arch Intern Med. 2001. PubMed 11434797
- Jha P, Ramasundarahettige C, Landsman V, et al. 21st-century hazards of smoking and benefits of cessation in the United States. N Engl J Med. 2013. PubMed 23343063
- Li Y, Pan A, Wang DD, et al. Impact of healthy lifestyle factors on life expectancies in the US population. Circulation. 2018. PubMed 29712712
- Paluch AE, Bajpai S, Bassett DR, et al. Daily steps and all-cause mortality: a meta-analysis of 15 international cohorts. Lancet Public Health. 2022. PubMed 35247352
- Holt-Lunstad J, Smith TB, Layton JB. Social relationships and mortality risk: a meta-analytic review. PLoS Med. 2010. PubMed 20668659
- Alimujiang A, Wiensch A, Boss J, et al. Association between life purpose and mortality among US adults older than 50 years. JAMA Netw Open. 2019. PubMed 31125099
- Orlich MJ, Singh PN, Sabaté J, et al. Vegetarian dietary patterns and mortality in Adventist Health Study 2. JAMA Intern Med. 2013. PubMed 23836264
- Thompson AS, Tresserra-Rimbau A, Karavasiloglou N, et al. Association of healthful plant-based diet adherence with risk of mortality and major chronic diseases among adults in the UK. JAMA Netw Open. 2023. PubMed 36976560
- Estruch R, Ros E, Salas-Salvadó J, et al. Primary prevention of cardiovascular disease with a Mediterranean diet supplemented with extra-virgin olive oil or nuts. N Engl J Med. 2018. PubMed 29897866
- Zhao J, Stockwell T, Naimi T, et al. Association between daily alcohol intake and risk of all-cause mortality: a systematic review and meta-analyses. JAMA Netw Open. 2023. PubMed 37000449
- Hokama T, Binns C. Declining longevity advantage and low birthweight in Okinawa. Asia Pac J Public Health. 2008. PubMed 19533867
Newsletter · Weekly
The weekly peptide briefing.
New guides, the week’s peptide news, one tool. Free, one email a week, unsubscribe anytime.