# Tirzepatide vs semaglutide: SURMOUNT-5 weight loss

Source: https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-5-2025

Last updated: 2026-11-17

Use: © PepVault. Read and cite with a link. Copying, bulk scraping, rewriting or republishing is not permitted (https://pepvault.app/terms#content).

[Research](https://pepvault.app/research) [Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/research#tirzepatide)

Randomized trial · people

# Tirzepatide: 20.2% weight loss vs 13.7% on semaglutide at 72 weeks

Checked against the paper November 2026 Randomized trial [Published by PepVault](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research)

## The takeaway

In a direct head-to-head trial, tirzepatide led to more weight and waist loss than semaglutide over 72 weeks, and gut-related side effects were the most common in both groups.

- **Kind:** Randomized trial
- **Studied in:** People
- **Number studied:** 751
- **Published:** 2025
- **Journal:** N Engl J Med

## What they tested

The team tested whether tirzepatide or semaglutide led to more weight loss in adults with obesity who did not have type 2 diabetes.

## How the study was done

A phase 3b, randomized, open-label trial in 751 adults with obesity but without type 2 diabetes. Each person was assigned to the highest dose they could tolerate of either tirzepatide (10 mg or 15 mg) or semaglutide (1.7 mg or 2.4 mg), injected under the skin once a week for 72 weeks.

<!--promo-->

Model. Individual results vary.

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking tirzepatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?ppid=616838ec-3248-400f-bd58-4b93f85f1a20&pt=129020030&ct=study-card-flow&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

<!--/promo-->

## What they found

At week 72, body weight changed by an average of -20.2% on tirzepatide and -13.7% on semaglutide (P<0.001). Waist size shrank by 18.4 cm on tirzepatide and 13.0 cm on semaglutide (P<0.001). People on tirzepatide were more likely to lose at least 10%, 15%, 20% and 25% of their weight. In both groups the most common side effects were gut-related, mostly mild to moderate, and they came mainly while doses were being raised.

## What it doesn’t show

It was an open-label trial rather than a blinded one, and it was funded by Eli Lilly. It included only adults without type 2 diabetes, so it does not show how the two drugs compare in people with diabetes.

## The paper

Aronne et al. Tirzepatide as Compared with Semaglutide for the Treatment of Obesity. N Engl J Med. 2025.

- [PubMed (PMID 40353578)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40353578/)
- [The paper (DOI 10.1056/NEJMoa2416394)](https://doi.org/10.1056/NEJMoa2416394)
- [ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT05822830)](https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT05822830)

## The compounds

- [Tirzepatide: how it works, half-life, studied range and evidence](https://pepvault.app/peptides/tirzepatide)
- [Semaglutide: how it works, half-life, studied range and evidence](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Tirzepatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/tirzepatide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)

## With this study

### Tirzepatide

- [Tirzepatide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/tirzepatide)
- [Tirzepatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/tirzepatide)

### Semaglutide

- [Semaglutide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)

### Mixing charts

- [Tirzepatide 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-5mg)
- [Tirzepatide 10 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-10mg)
- [Tirzepatide 15 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-15mg)
- [Tirzepatide 30 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-30mg)
- [Tirzepatide 60 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-60mg)
- [Semaglutide 2 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-2mg)
- [Semaglutide 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-5mg)
- [Semaglutide 10 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-10mg)

### Studies

- [Tirzepatide plus apitegromab: 1.9 kg less lean mass loss in EMBRAZE](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-embraze-2026)
- [Dulaglutide: switching to tirzepatide beat dose escalation on HbA1c](https://pepvault.app/research/dulaglutide-surpass-switch-2025)
- [Tirzepatide: up to 19.7% weight loss at 176 weeks in SURMOUNT-1](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-1-2025-39536238)
- [All 15 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#tirzepatide)
- [CagriSema: 18.4% weight loss vs 11.9% on semaglutide in REDEFINE 5](https://pepvault.app/research/cagrisema-redefine-5-2026)
- [Semaglutide (oral): smaller HbA1c drop than orforglipron in ACHIEVE-3](https://pepvault.app/research/semaglutide-achieve-3-2026)
- [Semaglutide (oral) did not slow early Alzheimer's in evoke trials](https://pepvault.app/research/semaglutide-oral-evoke-and-evoke-2026)
- [All 20 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#semaglutide)

### Compared with

- [Retatrutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/retatrutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Mazdutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/mazdutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Tirzepatide vs Liraglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/tirzepatide-vs-liraglutide)
- [Tirzepatide vs Dulaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/tirzepatide-vs-dulaglutide)
- [Orforglipron vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/orforglipron-vs-tirzepatide)

### Tools

- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)
- [How long will my vial last?](https://pepvault.app/tools/how-long-will-my-vial-last)
- [Is my mixed vial still good?](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstituted-peptide-expiry)
- [Half-life calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)
- [GLP-1 titration planner](https://pepvault.app/tools/glp1-titration-calculator)
- [GLP-1 weight loss by week](https://pepvault.app/tools/glp1-weight-loss-by-week)

## More studies on Tirzepatide

- [Tirzepatide plus apitegromab: 1.9 kg less lean mass loss in EMBRAZE](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-embraze-2026) Randomized trial · people · 2026
- [Dulaglutide: switching to tirzepatide beat dose escalation on HbA1c](https://pepvault.app/research/dulaglutide-surpass-switch-2025) Randomized trial · people · 2025
- [Tirzepatide: up to 19.7% weight loss at 176 weeks in SURMOUNT-1](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-1-2025-39536238) Randomized trial · people · 2025
- [Tirzepatide: about 75% of weight lost was fat in SURMOUNT-1](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-1-2025-39996356) Randomized trial · people · 2025
- [Tirzepatide: most reached a weight plateau by week 72 in SURMOUNT-1](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-1-and-surmount-4-2025) Randomized trial · people · 2025
- [Tirzepatide: up to 17.5% weight loss at 52 weeks in SURMOUNT-CN](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-cn-2024) Randomized trial · people · 2024
- [Every study on Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/research#tirzepatide)

Researched and drafted with AI, then checked claim by claim against the primary sources linked below by a separate review pass. Published by PepVault. Last reviewed November 2026. Spot an error? [feedback@pepvault.app](mailto:feedback@pepvault.app). [How we research](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research). This page reports one study; it is not medical advice.

<!--promo-->

[Track it in the app](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?ppid=616838ec-3248-400f-bd58-4b93f85f1a20&pt=129020030&ct=study-card-next&mt=8)

<!--/promo-->

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking tirzepatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?ppid=616838ec-3248-400f-bd58-4b93f85f1a20&pt=129020030&ct=study-card-end&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

[Explore the live demo](https://pepvault.app/login)

<!--/promo-->

<!--promo-->

Model. Individual results vary.

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking tirzepatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?ppid=616838ec-3248-400f-bd58-4b93f85f1a20&pt=129020030&ct=study-card-rail&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

<!--/promo-->

## With this study

### Tirzepatide

- [Tirzepatide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/tirzepatide)
- [Tirzepatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/tirzepatide)

### Semaglutide

- [Semaglutide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)

### Mixing charts

- [Tirzepatide 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-5mg)
- [Tirzepatide 10 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-10mg)
- [Tirzepatide 15 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-15mg)
- [Tirzepatide 30 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-30mg)
- [Tirzepatide 60 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/tirzepatide-60mg)
- [Semaglutide 2 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-2mg)
- [Semaglutide 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-5mg)
- [Semaglutide 10 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-10mg)

### Studies

- [Tirzepatide plus apitegromab: 1.9 kg less lean mass loss in EMBRAZE](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-embraze-2026)
- [Dulaglutide: switching to tirzepatide beat dose escalation on HbA1c](https://pepvault.app/research/dulaglutide-surpass-switch-2025)
- [Tirzepatide: up to 19.7% weight loss at 176 weeks in SURMOUNT-1](https://pepvault.app/research/tirzepatide-surmount-1-2025-39536238)
- [All 15 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#tirzepatide)
- [CagriSema: 18.4% weight loss vs 11.9% on semaglutide in REDEFINE 5](https://pepvault.app/research/cagrisema-redefine-5-2026)
- [Semaglutide (oral): smaller HbA1c drop than orforglipron in ACHIEVE-3](https://pepvault.app/research/semaglutide-achieve-3-2026)
- [Semaglutide (oral) did not slow early Alzheimer's in evoke trials](https://pepvault.app/research/semaglutide-oral-evoke-and-evoke-2026)
- [All 20 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#semaglutide)

### Compared with

- [Retatrutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/retatrutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Mazdutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/mazdutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Tirzepatide vs Liraglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/tirzepatide-vs-liraglutide)
- [Tirzepatide vs Dulaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/tirzepatide-vs-dulaglutide)
- [Orforglipron vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/orforglipron-vs-tirzepatide)

### Tools

- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)
- [How long will my vial last?](https://pepvault.app/tools/how-long-will-my-vial-last)
- [Is my mixed vial still good?](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstituted-peptide-expiry)
- [Half-life calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)
- [GLP-1 titration planner](https://pepvault.app/tools/glp1-titration-calculator)
- [GLP-1 weight loss by week](https://pepvault.app/tools/glp1-weight-loss-by-week)

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking tirzepatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?ppid=616838ec-3248-400f-bd58-4b93f85f1a20&pt=129020030&ct=study-card-sticky&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

[Explore the live demo](https://pepvault.app/login)

<!--/promo-->

## Research

- [All studies](https://pepvault.app/research)
- [Every study on Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/research#tirzepatide)

## The library

- [Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/tirzepatide)
- [Tirzepatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/tirzepatide)
- [Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)
- [The peptide reference library](https://pepvault.app/peptides)

## How we work

- [How we research](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research)
- [How we check the library](https://pepvault.app/about#library)

PepVault is a research and tracking resource, not medical advice. Ranges are what studies used, never a dose for you. Brand names are trademarks of their owners; PepVault is independent of them.

PepVault is a private research and tracking tool, not medical advice. The information here is reference material from published literature and community use — always verify it and discuss any protocol with a qualified clinician before changing it. Ozempic, Wegovy, Rybelsus, Mounjaro, Zepbound, Saxenda, Victoza and Trulicity are trademarks of their respective owners; PepVault is independent and not affiliated with or endorsed by any manufacturer.

© 2026 PepVault. Our text, data and tools may not be copied, scraped or republished without [permission](https://pepvault.app/terms#content).
