# Exenatide ER vs semaglutide: SUSTAIN 3 HbA1c and weight

Source: https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-sustain-3-2018

Last updated: 2026-11-18

Use: © PepVault. Read and cite with a link. Copying, bulk scraping, rewriting or republishing is not permitted (https://pepvault.app/terms#content).

[Research](https://pepvault.app/research) [Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/research#exenatide)

Randomized trial · people

# Exenatide ER: 0.9% HbA1c drop vs 1.5% with semaglutide in SUSTAIN 3

Checked against the paper November 2026 Randomized trial [Published by PepVault](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research)

## The takeaway

Head to head over 56 weeks, exenatide ER 2.0 mg lowered HbA1c and weight less than semaglutide 1.0 mg, with fewer gut side effects but more injection-site reactions.

- **Kind:** Randomized trial
- **Studied in:** People
- **Number studied:** 813
- **Published:** 2018
- **Journal:** Diabetes Care

## What they tested

The team tested whether once-weekly semaglutide 1.0 mg lowers blood sugar as well as or better than exenatide extended release (ER) 2.0 mg in people with type 2 diabetes.

## How the study was done

A randomized, open-label, phase 3a trial (everyone knew which drug they got) in 813 adults with type 2 diabetes already on diabetes pills, split evenly between semaglutide 1.0 mg and exenatide ER 2.0 mg for 56 weeks. The main measure was the change in HbA1c, a 3-month average of blood sugar.

<!--promo-->

Model. Individual results vary.

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking exenatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=study-card-flow&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

<!--/promo-->

## What they found

From a starting HbA1c of 8.3%, the exenatide ER arm dropped 0.9% and the semaglutide arm dropped 1.5%, an estimated gap of -0.62% in favor of semaglutide. Body weight, 95.8 kg at the start, fell 1.9 kg with exenatide ER and 5.6 kg with semaglutide. An HbA1c under 7.0% was reached by 40% on exenatide ER and 67% on semaglutide. Stomach and gut side effects hit 33.3% on exenatide ER and 41.8% on semaglutide, but reactions where the shot went in showed up in 22.0% of the exenatide ER arm, against 1.2% of the semaglutide arm.

## What it doesn’t show

The trial was open-label and tested a single dose of each drug, only in people whose diabetes was not controlled on pills. It ran for 56 weeks, so it does not show longer-term results.

## The paper

Ahmann et al. Efficacy and Safety of Once-Weekly Semaglutide Versus Exenatide ER in Subjects With Type 2 Diabetes (SUSTAIN 3): A 56-Week, Open-Label, Randomized Clinical Trial. Diabetes Care. 2018.

- [PubMed (PMID 29246950)](https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29246950/)
- [The paper (DOI 10.2337/dc17-0417)](https://doi.org/10.2337/dc17-0417)
- [ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT01885208)](https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT01885208)

## The compounds

- [Exenatide: how it works, half-life, studied range and evidence](https://pepvault.app/peptides/exenatide)
- [Semaglutide: how it works, half-life, studied range and evidence](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Exenatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/exenatide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)

## With this study

### Exenatide

- [Exenatide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/exenatide)
- [Exenatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/exenatide)

### Semaglutide

- [Semaglutide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)

### Mixing charts

- [Semaglutide 2 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-2mg)
- [Semaglutide 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-5mg)
- [Semaglutide 10 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-10mg)

### Studies

- [Exenatide: no cognitive benefit in mild cognitive impairment](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-dei-cas-2024)
- [Exenatide: lower intracranial pressure in IIH over 12 weeks](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-mitchell-2023)
- [Exenatide did not cut heavy drinking days in alcohol use disorder](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-klausen-2022)
- [All 8 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#exenatide)
- [Semaglutide: 11.85% more weight loss than placebo without diabetes](https://pepvault.app/research/semaglutide-tan-2022)
- [CagriSema: 18.4% weight loss vs 11.9% on semaglutide in REDEFINE 5](https://pepvault.app/research/cagrisema-redefine-5-2026)
- [CagriSema: HbA1c down 2.33% at 40 weeks in REIMAGINE 3](https://pepvault.app/research/cagrisema-reimagine-3-2026)
- [All 31 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#semaglutide)

### Compared with

- [Semaglutide vs Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-exenatide)
- [Liraglutide vs Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/liraglutide-vs-exenatide)
- [Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Retatrutide vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/retatrutide-vs-semaglutide)
- [Orforglipron vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/orforglipron-vs-semaglutide)
- [Cagrilintide vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/cagrilintide-vs-semaglutide)

### Tools

- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)
- [How long will my vial last?](https://pepvault.app/tools/how-long-will-my-vial-last)
- [Is my mixed vial still good?](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstituted-peptide-expiry)
- [Half-life calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)

### Terms on this page

- [Open-label](https://pepvault.app/glossary/open-label)
- [HbA1c (A1C)](https://pepvault.app/glossary/hba1c)

## More studies on Exenatide

- [Exenatide: no cognitive benefit in mild cognitive impairment](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-dei-cas-2024) Randomized trial · people · 2024
- [Exenatide: lower intracranial pressure in IIH over 12 weeks](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-mitchell-2023) Randomized trial · people · 2023
- [Exenatide did not cut heavy drinking days in alcohol use disorder](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-klausen-2022) Randomized trial · people · 2022
- [Exenatide: 29.2% spontaneous pregnancy vs 14.7% on metformin in PCOS](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-li-2022) Randomized trial · people · 2022
- [Exenatide plus dapagliflozin: UACR fell 39.6% vs 11.0% on placebo](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-decrease-2021) Randomized trial · people · 2021
- [Exenatide, alone or with dapagliflozin, improved blood sugar in PCOS](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-elkind-hirsch-2021) Randomized trial · people · 2021
- [Every study on Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/research#exenatide)

Researched and drafted with AI, then checked claim by claim against the primary sources linked below by a separate review pass. Published by PepVault. Last reviewed November 2026. Spot an error? [feedback@pepvault.app](mailto:feedback@pepvault.app). [How we research](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research). This page reports one study; it is not medical advice.

<!--promo-->

[Track it in the app](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=study-card-next&mt=8)

<!--/promo-->

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking exenatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=study-card-end&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

[Explore the live demo](https://pepvault.app/login)

<!--/promo-->

<!--promo-->

Model. Individual results vary.

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking exenatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=study-card-rail&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

<!--/promo-->

## With this study

### Exenatide

- [Exenatide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/exenatide)
- [Exenatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/exenatide)

### Semaglutide

- [Semaglutide: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)

### Mixing charts

- [Semaglutide 2 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-2mg)
- [Semaglutide 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-5mg)
- [Semaglutide 10 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/semaglutide-10mg)

### Studies

- [Exenatide: no cognitive benefit in mild cognitive impairment](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-dei-cas-2024)
- [Exenatide: lower intracranial pressure in IIH over 12 weeks](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-mitchell-2023)
- [Exenatide did not cut heavy drinking days in alcohol use disorder](https://pepvault.app/research/exenatide-klausen-2022)
- [All 8 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#exenatide)
- [Semaglutide: 11.85% more weight loss than placebo without diabetes](https://pepvault.app/research/semaglutide-tan-2022)
- [CagriSema: 18.4% weight loss vs 11.9% on semaglutide in REDEFINE 5](https://pepvault.app/research/cagrisema-redefine-5-2026)
- [CagriSema: HbA1c down 2.33% at 40 weeks in REIMAGINE 3](https://pepvault.app/research/cagrisema-reimagine-3-2026)
- [All 31 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#semaglutide)

### Compared with

- [Semaglutide vs Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-exenatide)
- [Liraglutide vs Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/liraglutide-vs-exenatide)
- [Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Retatrutide vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/retatrutide-vs-semaglutide)
- [Orforglipron vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/orforglipron-vs-semaglutide)
- [Cagrilintide vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/cagrilintide-vs-semaglutide)

### Tools

- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)
- [How long will my vial last?](https://pepvault.app/tools/how-long-will-my-vial-last)
- [Is my mixed vial still good?](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstituted-peptide-expiry)
- [Half-life calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)

### Terms on this page

- [Open-label](https://pepvault.app/glossary/open-label)
- [HbA1c (A1C)](https://pepvault.app/glossary/hba1c)

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking exenatide? Keep your own record

Log each dose, your weight and how you feel, in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=study-card-sticky&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

[Explore the live demo](https://pepvault.app/login)

<!--/promo-->

## Research

- [All studies](https://pepvault.app/research)
- [Every study on Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/research#exenatide)

## The library

- [Exenatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/exenatide)
- [Exenatide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/exenatide)
- [Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/semaglutide)
- [Semaglutide dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/semaglutide)
- [The peptide reference library](https://pepvault.app/peptides)

## How we work

- [How we research](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research)
- [How we check the library](https://pepvault.app/about#library)

PepVault is a research and tracking resource, not medical advice. Ranges are what studies used, never a dose for you. Brand names are trademarks of their owners; PepVault is independent of them.

PepVault is a private research and tracking tool, not medical advice. The information here is reference material from published literature and community use — always verify it and discuss any protocol with a qualified clinician before changing it. Ozempic, Wegovy, Rybelsus, Mounjaro, Zepbound, Saxenda, Victoza and Trulicity are trademarks of their respective owners; PepVault is independent and not affiliated with or endorsed by any manufacturer.

© 2026 PepVault. Our text, data and tools may not be copied, scraped or republished without [permission](https://pepvault.app/terms#content).
