# Melanotan I vs Melanotan II: How They Differ | PepVault

Source: https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/melanotan-i-vs-melanotan-ii

Last updated: 2026-10-06

Use: © PepVault. Read and cite with a link. Copying, bulk scraping, rewriting or republishing is not permitted (https://pepvault.app/terms#content).

[Library](https://pepvault.app/peptides) [Comparisons](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare) Melanotan I vs Melanotan II

Compared side by side

# Melanotan I vs Melanotan II: how they differ

Reviewed October 2026 [How we check the library](https://pepvault.app/about#library) [Published by PepVault](https://pepvault.app/guides/how-we-research)

## The short answer

Both are synthetic relatives of α-MSH, the skin’s own tanning hormone, and the difference is reach: Melanotan I binds mainly MC1R, the receptor on pigment cells, while Melanotan II acts on MC1R, MC3R, MC4R and MC5R, so it also raises libido through the brain and can reduce appetite. Melanotan I’s only approval is Scenesse, a slow-release implant for the light-sensitivity disorder EPP. Commonly reported: a slower, more even tan on Melanotan I with less nausea and few libido effects, and on Melanotan II a fast, deep tan with nausea and flushing after the first doses.

## Side by side

| Compared | [Melanotan I](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-i) | [Melanotan II](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-ii) |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Category | Sexual health | Sexual health |
| Also known as | MT-1, MT1, Melanotan 1, Afamelanotide, Scenesse, CUV1647, NDP-MSH | MT-2, MT2, Melanotan 2 |
| What it is | Afamelanotide, the tanning-focused cousin of Melanotan II: a synthetic version of the skin's tanning hormone that darkens skin through the pigment receptor MC1R, with or without sun. | A broad-spectrum melanocortin agonist originally developed for sunless tanning. |
| How it works | Synthetic analogue of α-MSH, the skin's own tanning hormone ([Nle4, D-Phe7]-α-MSH, generic name afamelanotide): a linear peptide that binds mainly MC1R, the receptor on pigment cells, and raises eumelanin, the dark pigment that filters UV, with or without sun. It is the tanning-focused relative of Melanotan II, whose later trials were in erectile dysfunction. Approved only as Scenesse, a slow-release 16 mg implant for the light-sensitivity disorder erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP). | Melanocortin receptor agonist (MC1R, MC3R, MC4R, MC5R). Stimulates melanogenesis (skin tanning), increases libido via CNS pathways, and can reduce appetite (a side effect in one small trial; the MC4R appetite mechanism comes from rodent work). Structurally similar to alpha-MSH. |
| Commonly reported | A slower, more even tan than with MT-2, less nausea and few of its libido effects; freckles and moles darken along with the tan. | Nausea and facial flushing after the first doses, easing with continued use; a fast, deep tan with freckles and moles visibly darkening; and spontaneous erections, frequent yawning and reduced appetite. Monitor moles carefully — it darkens all pigmented skin, and FDA cites melanoma reports. |
| Studied range | Research range: 250–1000 mcg, starting dose 250 mcg. Studied in research — not a recommendation. FDA-approved as Scenesse (afamelanotide): one 16 mg implant placed under the skin by a trained clinician every 2 months, to increase pain-free light exposure in adults with erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP). | Research range: 250–500 mcg. Studied in research — not a recommendation. |
| How often | Loading: daily for 10–14 days. Maintenance: 1–3 times a week. | Loading: 250mcg daily for 1-2 weeks. Maintenance: 250-500mcg 2-3x/week or as needed. |
| Half-life | ~0.8–1.7 hours (measured in three people after SubQ injection; the slow-release implant's apparent half-life is about 15 hours, per its label) | Unknown in humans |
| Route | SubQ injection, Implant (Scenesse, clinic only) | SubQ injection |
| Typical run | Community courses: a 10–14 day daily loading phase, then a few doses a week to hold the tan. Trials used mostly 10-day courses at far higher doses (0.08–0.21 mg/kg a day); the approved implant is one 16 mg implant every 2 months. Sun or UV adds to the tan. | Loading phase until desired tan achieved, then reduce to maintenance. Sun or UV exposure enhances tanning effect. |
| Evidence | Established: clinical trials or FDA-approved use exists | Emerging: primarily preclinical / limited human data |
| Common side effects | Nausea, facial flushing, darkening of moles and freckles, injection site reaction, fatigue | Nausea, facial flushing, spontaneous erections, fatigue, darkening of moles/freckles, yawning |

Typical run: Community practice — opinions vary. Not a clinical recommendation.

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking Melanotan I or Melanotan II? Log it in PepVault

Each dose, each vial and your step-ups in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=compound-vs-card-flow&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

<!--/promo-->

## Week by week

Each entry’s cards by day window, as the compound pages show them. Day 1 is the day you start it.

### Melanotan I

- Day 1–7 A gentler start than MT-2
- Day 8–21 The tan builds, sun or not
- Day 15+ Freckles and moles darken too
- Day 22–90 A tan that cut sunburn damage in a trial

[Every card for Melanotan I, with its sources](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-i#weeks)

### Melanotan II

- Day 1–3 Start low — your body needs to adjust
- Day 3–7 Melanocytes are waking up
- Day 7–14 The tan is developing
- Day 14–28 Transition to maintenance

[Every card for Melanotan II, with its sources](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-ii#weeks)

## With this comparison

### Melanotan I

- [Melanotan I: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-i)
- [Melanotan I dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/melanotan-i)

### Melanotan II

- [Melanotan II: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-ii)
- [Melanotan II dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/melanotan-ii)

### Mixing charts

- [Melanotan I 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/melanotan-i-5mg)
- [Melanotan II 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/melanotan-ii-5mg)

### Studies

- [Melanotan I: more pain-free sun time in protoporphyria trials](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-i-langendonk-2015)
- [Melanotan I plus UV-B: 48.64% vitiligo repigmentation at day 168](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-i-lim-2015)
- [Melanotan I: well tolerated in 6 acute stroke patients](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-i-stanislaus-2023)
- [All 6 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#melanotan-i)
- [Melanotan II: erections in 17 of 20 men with erectile dysfunction](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-ii-wessells-2000)
- [Melanotan II: erections in 8 of 10 men with psychogenic ED](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-ii-wessells-1998)
- [Melanotan II: darker skin in 2 of 3 men in a small phase I trial](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-ii-dorr-1996)
- [All 4 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#melanotan-ii)

### Compared with

- [PT-141 vs Melanotan II](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/pt-141-vs-melanotan-ii)

### Tools

- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)
- [How long will my vial last?](https://pepvault.app/tools/how-long-will-my-vial-last)
- [Is my mixed vial still good?](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstituted-peptide-expiry)
- [Half-life calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)

### Terms on this page

- [Peptide](https://pepvault.app/glossary/peptide)
- [Receptor agonist](https://pepvault.app/glossary/receptor-agonist)
- [Subcutaneous (SubQ)](https://pepvault.app/glossary/subcutaneous)
- [Half-life](https://pepvault.app/glossary/half-life)

## Questions people ask

### How long do Melanotan I and Melanotan II last?

The half-life of Melanotan I is ~0.8–1.7 hours (measured in three people after SubQ injection; the slow-release implant's apparent half-life is about 15 hours, per its label). The half-life of Melanotan II is unknown in humans.

### How often are Melanotan I and Melanotan II taken?

Melanotan I: loading: daily for 10–14 days. Maintenance: 1–3 times a week. Routes: SubQ injection, implant (Scenesse, clinic only). Melanotan II: loading: 250mcg daily for 1-2 weeks. Maintenance: 250-500mcg 2-3x/week or as needed. Route: SubQ injection.

### How are Melanotan I and Melanotan II dosed in research?

The research range for Melanotan I is 250–1000 mcg, with a 250 mcg starting dose. Studied in research — not a recommendation. FDA-approved as Scenesse (afamelanotide): one 16 mg implant placed under the skin by a trained clinician every 2 months, to increase pain-free light exposure in adults with erythropoietic protoporphyria (EPP). The research range for Melanotan II is 250–500 mcg. Studied in research — not a recommendation.

### What are the common side effects of Melanotan I and Melanotan II?

For Melanotan I, the library lists: nausea, facial flushing, darkening of moles and freckles, injection site reaction, fatigue. For Melanotan II: nausea, facial flushing, spontaneous erections, fatigue, darkening of moles/freckles, yawning.

## Each one in full

- [Melanotan I: dosage, half-life & reference guide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-i)
- [Melanotan II: dosage, half-life & reference guide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-ii)
- [Melanotan I dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/melanotan-i)
- [Melanotan II dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/melanotan-ii)

<!--promo-->

[Track it in the app](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=compound-vs-card-next&mt=8)

<!--/promo-->

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking Melanotan I or Melanotan II? Log it in PepVault

Each dose, each vial and your step-ups in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=compound-vs-card-end&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

[Explore the live demo](https://pepvault.app/login)

<!--/promo-->

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking Melanotan I or Melanotan II? Log it in PepVault

Each dose, each vial and your step-ups in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=compound-vs-card-rail&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

<!--/promo-->

## With this comparison

### Melanotan I

- [Melanotan I: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-i)
- [Melanotan I dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/melanotan-i)

### Melanotan II

- [Melanotan II: the full reference](https://pepvault.app/peptides/melanotan-ii)
- [Melanotan II dose guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage/melanotan-ii)

### Mixing charts

- [Melanotan I 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/melanotan-i-5mg)
- [Melanotan II 5 mg vial](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator/melanotan-ii-5mg)

### Studies

- [Melanotan I: more pain-free sun time in protoporphyria trials](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-i-langendonk-2015)
- [Melanotan I plus UV-B: 48.64% vitiligo repigmentation at day 168](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-i-lim-2015)
- [Melanotan I: well tolerated in 6 acute stroke patients](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-i-stanislaus-2023)
- [All 6 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#melanotan-i)
- [Melanotan II: erections in 17 of 20 men with erectile dysfunction](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-ii-wessells-2000)
- [Melanotan II: erections in 8 of 10 men with psychogenic ED](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-ii-wessells-1998)
- [Melanotan II: darker skin in 2 of 3 men in a small phase I trial](https://pepvault.app/research/melanotan-ii-dorr-1996)
- [All 4 studies](https://pepvault.app/research#melanotan-ii)

### Compared with

- [PT-141 vs Melanotan II](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/pt-141-vs-melanotan-ii)

### Tools

- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)
- [How long will my vial last?](https://pepvault.app/tools/how-long-will-my-vial-last)
- [Is my mixed vial still good?](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstituted-peptide-expiry)
- [Half-life calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)

### Terms on this page

- [Peptide](https://pepvault.app/glossary/peptide)
- [Receptor agonist](https://pepvault.app/glossary/receptor-agonist)
- [Subcutaneous (SubQ)](https://pepvault.app/glossary/subcutaneous)
- [Half-life](https://pepvault.app/glossary/half-life)

<!--promo-->

PepVault for iPhone

## Taking Melanotan I or Melanotan II? Log it in PepVault

Each dose, each vial and your step-ups in one place.

[Download on the App Store](https://apps.apple.com/app/apple-store/id6779318649?pt=129020030&ct=compound-vs-card-sticky&mt=8)

7 days free on the yearly plan for new subscribers.

[Explore the live demo](https://pepvault.app/login)

<!--/promo-->

## More comparisons

- [All peptide comparisons](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare)
- [PT-141 vs Melanotan II](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/pt-141-vs-melanotan-ii)
- [Retatrutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/retatrutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Semaglutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/semaglutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Retatrutide vs Semaglutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/retatrutide-vs-semaglutide)
- [Mazdutide vs Tirzepatide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/mazdutide-vs-tirzepatide)
- [Survodutide vs Retatrutide](https://pepvault.app/peptides/compare/survodutide-vs-retatrutide)

## The library

- [The peptide reference library](https://pepvault.app/peptides)
- [Sexual health peptides](https://pepvault.app/peptides#sexual-health)

## Free tools

- [The Dose Guide](https://pepvault.app/lab/dosage)
- [Half-life & active level](https://pepvault.app/tools/peptide-half-life-calculator)
- [Reconstitution calculator](https://pepvault.app/tools/reconstitution-calculator)

PepVault is a research and tracking resource, not medical advice. Ranges are what studies used, never a dose for you. Brand names are trademarks of their owners; PepVault is independent of them.

PepVault is a private research and tracking tool, not medical advice. The information here is reference material from published literature and community use — always verify it and discuss any protocol with a qualified clinician before changing it.

© 2026 PepVault. Our text, data and tools may not be copied, scraped or republished without [permission](https://pepvault.app/terms#content).
